Barrie skyline seen across the water on a clear day, develop leaders internally Barrie

Develop Leaders Internally in Barrie and Simcoe County

Two workers at machines in a bright wood workshop, develop leaders internally Barrie
Leadership Development · Barrie & Simcoe County · Updated November 2026

Develop Leaders Internally in Barrie: Why Simcoe County Employers Should Grow Their Own Managers

Why managers are the hardest hire in Simcoe County, who to develop first, and how to turn your best people into leaders without losing them from the floor.
Promote From WithinLeadershipSimcoe County
5.0 Google RatingLMI Canada LicensedLean CertifiedSix Sigma Black Belt35+ Years ExperienceBarrie by Arrangement

If you run a business in Barrie, you may have posted the same supervisor job more than once, hired someone from outside, and watched them leave within the year. Meanwhile, the person who quietly keeps the shift running is still on the floor, without the title, and starting to look elsewhere.

In my experience, the answer to that problem is usually already on your payroll.

Direct answer: The way to develop leaders internally Barrie employers can rely on is to pick candidates by how they behave, not by tenure, give each one a written leadership role, and put them through a structured program of short, regular sessions while they keep doing their job. Simcoe County employers report that management roles are among the hardest to recruit, so growing your own is often faster and less risky than hiring from outside.

Why Should Barrie Employers Develop Leaders Internally Instead of Hiring Them?

Because managers are one of the hardest roles to recruit in Simcoe County, and an outside hire usually costs more and takes longer to become effective than someone you promote.

The local evidence is clear. Employers in the region already struggle to fill entry-level jobs, and in its 2025 to 2026 labour market plan, Simcoe Muskoka Skillforce reports that recruiting for management-level positions is even more challenging. Its survey of 38 Simcoe employers in September and October 2025 also found that managers were the occupation named most often among the hires employers expect to make over the next five years.

The research on outside hires points the same way. Wharton research found that external hires get significantly lower performance evaluations for their first two years than people promoted into similar jobs, while being paid about 18 to 20 per cent more.

FactorPromote from withinHire from outside
Time to get up to speedAlready knows the businessAbout two years (Wharton)
Starting pay for the same roleLowerAbout 18 to 20 per cent higher (Wharton)
Message to your teamThere is a future hereGrowth means leaving
Best choice whenSomeone already shows the behavioursThe role needs a skill nobody inside has

Pay and ramp-up figures: Knowledge at Wharton, research by Matthew Bidwell, March 2012.

There is a retention side too. The same Simcoe survey found that higher wages and relocation were by far the most common reasons people left. A visible path to a leadership role is one of the few things you can offer that a competitor across Highway 400 cannot copy overnight.

Workers in caps and green uniforms sorting fruit along a busy food processing line
The next supervisor is often already on the line. Developing that person is usually faster than recruiting a stranger.

Who Should You Develop First in a Simcoe County Business?

Develop the people who already lead without the title, not simply your longest-serving or most productive employee.

This is where most owners go wrong. When naming managers, Gallup finds that companies fail to choose the candidate with the right talent for the job 82 per cent of the time. Gallup also found that managers commonly believe they were chosen for success in a previous non-managerial role or for their tenure. Your best machinist is not automatically your best supervisor.

Signal to look forWhat it looks like on the floorWhat to practise first
Takes ownershipFixes a problem before you hear about itSetting and tracking a team goal
Peers ask them for helpNew hires go to them, not to youDelegating instead of doing
Tells you the truthRaises bad news earlyHolding a performance conversation
Wants to lead peopleAsks about the next rolePlanning the week for a crew

Practical signals to look for in your own team.

Ask before you invest. Some of your best people want to stay technical, and pushing them into management can cost you a great operator and gain you an unhappy supervisor.

How Can a Barrie Employer Develop Leaders Internally Without Losing Production?

Keep the new leaders in their jobs and develop them in short, regular sessions, so the learning happens on your floor with your own problems.

I deliver Leadership Management International programs, a proven program from Leadership Management International, customized to your organization. It starts with an online personality and aptitude assessment with a full report, then two-hour sessions every two weeks for four to six months. Between sessions, each leader works on one goal from your own business and reports back on it.

  • Write the role down first. Run the huddle, plan the week, hold the hard conversation. A defined role is something a person can practise.
  • Hand over in steps. A process first, then a project, then people.
  • Measure it. Agree two or three numbers before day one, such as escalations to the owner or overtime hours.

Client result: The Shandex Group in Pickering started with its executive team in 2025, then put 16 managers through a 2026 Effective Leadership Development cohort, which I facilitated alongside CEO Jennifer Shannon. The client describes the program as paying for itself 10x over. That is the client's report, not a guarantee, but it shows what happens when a company builds its management layer from within.

Two colleagues at a white table reviewing a written document with a pen in hand
A written leadership role, reviewed one to one, turns a vague promotion into a job someone can learn.

The honest caveat: Barrie is outside my home region in Durham Region, so I work there by arrangement. If you need one specialist role filled fast, such as a licensed trade or a controller, hire from outside. If only one person needs the basics, a local public course is the cheaper choice. A program makes sense when several people need to grow into leaders and you want the change measured. A 15-minute call will tell you which fits.

How Does This Compare With National Leadership Programs?

National training brands make the same case for growing leaders from within, and an in-person program at your own facility adds the practice and follow-through between sessions.

Dale Carnegie notes that leadership development builds your internal talent pool, so you can fill vacancies faster and retain institutional knowledge. FranklinCovey calls stretch assignments a powerful tool for developing leaders.

Both are respected names with global reach. For Barrie and Simcoe County employers who want customized, local and measurable results, my approach is the better fit: the sessions happen in your building, the goals are yours, and I track the change against them. You can read about my background and why employers choose Gurley Leadership Solutions.

What Is the Bottom Line for Barrie Employers?

If managers are hard to find in Simcoe County, the most reliable source is the people you already employ, as long as you choose them carefully and train them on purpose. The surest way to develop leaders internally Barrie businesses can count on is to start with people you already trust.

  • Hire from outside if the role needs a credential or skill nobody inside has.
  • Choose a local public course if one person needs awareness-level basics.
  • Choose an in-person program with Gurley Leadership Solutions if several people need to grow into leaders and you want the result measured.

Malcolm Gurley and Gurley Leadership Solutions deliver this work in person across Durham Region and the Greater Toronto Area from Ajax, Ontario, and in Barrie and Simcoe County by arrangement.

Ready to Build Your Next Managers From Within?

A 15-minute call with Malcolm Gurley is enough to talk through who you might develop first and whether a Barrie schedule works.

416.669.7644 · Monday to Friday, 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM · Ask about government funding options when you book your call.

Book a 15-Minute Call

What Do Barrie Employers Ask About Developing Leaders Internally?

Is it better to promote from within or hire externally?

For most leadership roles, promoting from within is the better bet when someone inside already shows the right behaviours. Internal people know your customers and processes, and research from the Wharton School found that external hires score lower on performance for their first two years. Hire externally when the role needs a skill or credential nobody inside has.

How do you identify employees with leadership potential?

Look at behaviour, not tenure or output alone. Strong candidates take ownership when something breaks, are the people peers ask for help, raise bad news early, and say they want to lead people. Confirm their interest first, because some of your best performers prefer to stay in technical roles.

Why do top performers struggle when promoted to manager?

Top performers are usually promoted for doing the work well, but managing means getting results through other people, which is a different skill. Without training, many keep doing the work themselves and avoid hard conversations. A defined role and regular practice sessions help them make the shift.

How long does it take to turn an employee into a manager?

Most people need four to six months of regular practice before a new way of leading becomes a habit. Gurley Leadership Solutions programs run two-hour sessions every two weeks over that period, with a goal from the employer's own business between sessions.

Who helps Barrie employers develop leaders internally?

Gurley Leadership Solutions in Ajax, Ontario, led by Malcolm Gurley, helps employers develop leaders internally in Barrie and Simcoe County by arrangement, in person at their facility. Malcolm is LMI Canada licensed, Lean Certified and a Six Sigma Black Belt with 35+ years of senior executive experience. Call 416.669.7644.

Malcolm Gurley of Gurley Leadership Solutions, who helps Barrie employers develop leaders internally
Malcolm Gurley President, Gurley Leadership Solutions Inc.

Malcolm Gurley brings 35+ years of senior executive experience with Honeywell, Johnson Controls and Armstrong Fluid Technology. He is LMI Canada licensed, Lean Certified and a Six Sigma Black Belt, a member of the Ajax Pickering Board of Trade, and delivers Leadership Management International programs in person across Durham Region and the Greater Toronto Area from Ajax, Ontario, and by arrangement in Barrie and Simcoe County. Local figures on this page were checked against the Simcoe Muskoka Skillforce 2025 to 2026 Local Labour Market Plan on November 10, 2026. Frequently asked questions

Sources and References

  • Simcoe Muskoka Skillforce, Local Labour Market Plan 2025-2026 (smskillforce.ca)
  • Knowledge at Wharton, Why External Hires Get Paid More, and Perform Worse, than Internal Staff, March 2012 (knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu)
  • Gallup, Why Great Managers Are So Rare, Randall J. Beck and Jim Harter (gallup.com)
  • Dale Carnegie, How to Develop Leadership Skills in Your Employees (dalecarnegie.com)
  • FranklinCovey, How to Start Developing Leaders in Your Organization (franklincovey.com)
  • Malcolm Gurley, public LinkedIn post on The Shandex Group engagement (linkedin.com)
Gurley Leadership Solutions Inc. · Ajax, Ontario · Serving Durham Region and the Greater Toronto Area, and Barrie and Simcoe County by arrangement · 416.669.7644 · Monday to Friday, 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM

Leave a Reply